The path to Equipment as a Service › Risk

Core question 3 of 6Share value

Core question 3 · Risk

How to manage risks?

Where do fluctuations come from, and who bears them? A usage-based model distributes risks instead of leaving them with one side. To do so, you have to know, measure and price them. Every driver is both a risk and an opportunity.

Value and volatility drivers – where risks and opportunities come from

Illustrative, qualitative example for a machine manufacturer.

Driver
Example
Opportunity
Handling the riskBearManageTransfer
Instruments
Financial
Price development
Falling component prices
low
mainly transfer
Contract term, price adjustment clause
Operating cash flow
Utilization of the equipment
high
mainly manage
Cost-based price, base fee
Credit risk
Payment default, collateral
medium
mainly manage
Analyze usage data
Operational
Technology
Service life of components
medium
mainly manage
Manufacturer warranties, dynamic price
Intensity of use
Operating hours and shifts
medium
mainly manage
Usage-based price
Type of use
Maintenance effort and need
medium
mainly manage
Maintenance-based price
Strategic
Customer retention
Access to usage and condition data
high
mainly manage
Ongoing service relationship instead of a one-off sale
New technologies
New equipment generations
low
mainly manage
Added value through new functions
Competitors
Providers from low-cost countries
low
mainly bear
Differentiation on price

From source to measure – in three steps

For each source of volatility we define what is transferred, what is managed and what is borne.

1Understand the sources of volatility
2Design measures
3Test acceptance, set up reporting
Sources of volatility
Transfer or avoidContractual framework · Insurance · Risk transfer
ManageControl over the equipment · Conflict resolution
BearPricing · Flexible capacity
MarketEconomic cycle

InsuranceHedging

TransferFlexible refinancing: repayment follows utilization

ControlAdjust maintenance and operating costs to utilization

CapacityAdjust capacity

PricingPrice flexibility

Business modelLoss of market share

ContractMinimum purchase commitment

As with market fluctuations
As with market fluctuations
Counterparty default

ContractSelect customers with good credit standing

ControlRemote shutdown or termination as negotiating leverage

Operation

InsuranceFire and business interruption insurance

Behaviore.g. only peak load in the usage-based model

ContractClarify responsibilities, minimum fee

ControlExclusive supply or role as capacity provider

PricingPrice floor and installation fee

Technology

TransferSource purchased parts on a usage basis as well

Conflict resolutionService level agreements and arbitration

  • Define the right billing metrics
  • Ensure that they can be measured objectively
  • Set up risk reports for investors and insurers

Deep dive 3 · Risk

Who bears which risk?

With purchase, leasing or rental the risk essentially sits with one side. A usage-based model distributes it. To do so, you have to know, measure and price it.

1 · Reduce

Equipment, service and consumables as a package reduce total costs and downtime.

2 · Detect

Usage and condition data show risks continuously.

3 · Price

The price follows the risk, dynamically if needed.

4 · Transfer

What remains goes to whoever can bear it best.

Four risks, their levers and their best bearer

RiskWhere it comes fromLeversBest bearer (example)
UtilizationVolumes fluctuate with the user’s business.Minimum purchase commitment, price tiers by committed flexibility, pooling across several usersUser and provider
Technology and performanceThe equipment does not reach its availability or output.Availability guarantee, condition monitoring, maintenance includedManufacturer
Residual valueThe value at the end of the contract is uncertain.Modular design, reuse, take-backOperator or manufacturer
Ability to payA user defaults.Credit assessment, diversification in the pool, guaranteesFinancier; for industry-wide solutions also the public sector

The allocation is illustrative and depends on industry and contract.

Check-up

Does your business case for shared value and distributed risks hold up?

We examine this with you in workshops before a model is developed.

Request a check-up