The path to Equipment as a Service › Balance sheet and financing

Core question 5 of 6Finance and scale

Core question 5 · Balance sheet and financing

How to relieve the balance sheet?

Three ways for entire industries to finance large retrofits without overburdening company balance sheets. Developed and assessed in the study on the Digital Automatic Coupling for the German Federal Ministry of Transport.

Who bears it?Which structure?How implemented?Special feature
Public sector shares the burdenIndustry bears it alone
Option 1

Financing company

Public sector: equity stake and guarantees
Company procures the assets
Companies use them under hire purchase
Preferred by the stakeholders surveyed.
Option 2

Public-sector covered bonds

Public sector: collateralization
Covered bonds finance the procurement
Wagon keepers procure themselves
The assets remain with the keepers.
Option 3

Industry solution

Companies in the industry organize themselves
Joint financing structure
Refinancing on the capital market
The industry carries the solution itself.

Deep dive 1 · Financing

How can the model be refinanced?

As long as the provider holds the equipment itself, its balance sheet grows with every contract. To scale, the equipment has to move to investors.

Usage contract

The provider concludes a contract with the customer for usage or outcome.

Special purpose vehicle

After the contract is signed, the equipment moves to a separate company.

Investors

Institutional investors finance this company, separate from the provider.

Usage revenues

The customers’ ongoing payments service the financing.

Usage and machine data generate the invoice and flow back into accounting. The model can also be integrated into an existing refinancing setup, such as a leasing company.

Six structures, from equity participation to sale

Provider’s shareInvestor’s shareShares shown schematically

Equity investor

51 %49 %

An investor takes a stake in the company that holds the equipment. The provider keeps the majority.

Equity partner

25 %75 %

The provider gives up the majority and remains involved as a partner.

Project finance or leasing

25 %75 %

In addition, a bank finances the equipment in the company.

Securitization

via special purpose vehicle

A special purpose vehicle buys the equipment and issues securities in several tranches.

Fund structure

95 %

A fund holds the equipment. The provider takes only a small stake.

Full sale

100 %

The equipment goes entirely to investors. The provider delivers service and administration.

Consolidation at the provider likelyConsolidation unlikely

What matters when scaling

Pricing

Overly cautious prices with short payback attract poor risks. Higher costs, higher prices and an even worse customer selection follow.

True sale

Beyond a certain size, flexible refinancing is needed so that the provider’s balance sheet and earnings are not burdened.

Billing

In the pilot phase it may be pragmatic. With external refinancing it has to become robust and auditable, without a large IT project.

Deep dive 2 · Balance sheet effect

When does the user not have to recognize the equipment on its balance sheet?

Under IFRS 16, a lease exists when the user controls the use of an identified asset. The equipment then appears on its balance sheet. Three test questions decide this. If one answer is no, it is generally a service and not a lease.

Is a specific asset identified?

Design lever: a pool of similar assets and a genuine substitution right for the provider.

No

Not a lease but a service

Does the user obtain substantially all of the economic benefits?

Design lever: the equipment is used across several users.

No

Not a lease but a service

Does the user direct how and for what purpose the equipment is used?

Design lever: the provider schedules the equipment, the user orders the service.

No

Not a lease but a service

Three times yes

Lease: right-of-use asset and liability appear on the user’s balance sheet.

Variable fees

Even if a lease exists, payments that depend solely on usage are not included in the recognized liability.

More than balance sheet cosmetics

Unlike leasing or rental, a usage-based model also stabilizes cash flows, because costs follow usage and thus revenue.

The presentation is simplified and does not replace accounting advice. The assessment in each individual case is made by the auditor.